Notice

Undefined offset: 483

ee/legacy/libraries/relationship_parser/Parser.php, line 39

Notice

Trying to access array offset on value of type null

ee/legacy/libraries/Channel_entries_parser.php, line 165

Notice

Trying to access array offset on value of type null

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 386

Notice

Undefined index: entry_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 209

Notice

Undefined index: entry_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 210

Notice

Undefined index: entry_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 212

Notice

Undefined index: site_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 213

Notice

Undefined index: site_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 217

Notice

Undefined index: entry_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 217

Notice

Undefined index: site_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 255

Notice

Undefined index: site_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Custom_field_pair.php, line 82

Notice

Undefined index: entry_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 55

Notice

Undefined index: edit_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 56

Notice

Undefined index: recent_comment_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 57

Notice

Undefined index: expiration_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 58

Notice

Undefined index: comment_expiration_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 59

Notice

Undefined index: entry_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 83

Notice

Undefined index: entry_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 83

Notice

Undefined index: entry_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 88

Notice

Undefined index: entry_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 89

Notice

Undefined index: edit_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 90

Notice

Undefined index: allow_comments

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 650

Notice

Undefined index: comment_expiration_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 664

Notice

Undefined index: channel_title

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 524

Notice

Undefined index: channel_name

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 525

Notice

Undefined index: screen_name

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 526

Notice

Undefined index: username

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 526

Notice

Undefined index: photo_width

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 528

Notice

Undefined index: photo_height

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 529

Notice

Undefined index: avatar_width

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 531

Notice

Undefined index: avatar_height

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 532

Notice

Undefined index: sig_img_width

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 534

Notice

Undefined index: sig_img_height

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 535

Notice

Undefined index: entry_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 536

Notice

Undefined index: site_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 553

Notice

Undefined index: entry_site_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Simple_variable.php, line 63

Notice

Undefined index: channel_url

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Simple_variable.php, line 64

Notice

Undefined index: comment_url

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Simple_variable.php, line 65

Notice

Undefined index: site_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Custom_field.php, line 54

Notice

Undefined offset: 483

ee/legacy/libraries/relationship_parser/Parser.php, line 39

Notice

Trying to access array offset on value of type null

ee/legacy/libraries/Channel_entries_parser.php, line 165

Notice

Trying to access array offset on value of type null

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 386

Notice

Undefined index: entry_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 209

Notice

Undefined index: entry_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 210

Notice

Undefined index: entry_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 212

Notice

Undefined index: site_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 213

Notice

Undefined index: site_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 217

Notice

Undefined index: entry_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 217

Notice

Undefined index: site_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 255

Notice

Undefined index: site_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Custom_field_pair.php, line 82

Notice

Undefined index: entry_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 55

Notice

Undefined index: edit_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 56

Notice

Undefined index: recent_comment_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 57

Notice

Undefined index: expiration_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 58

Notice

Undefined index: comment_expiration_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 59

Notice

Undefined index: entry_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 83

Notice

Undefined index: entry_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 83

Notice

Undefined index: entry_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 88

Notice

Undefined index: entry_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 89

Notice

Undefined index: edit_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Date.php, line 90

Notice

Undefined index: allow_comments

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 650

Notice

Undefined index: comment_expiration_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 664

Notice

Undefined index: channel_title

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 524

Notice

Undefined index: channel_name

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 525

Notice

Undefined index: screen_name

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 526

Notice

Undefined index: username

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 526

Notice

Undefined index: photo_width

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 528

Notice

Undefined index: photo_height

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 529

Notice

Undefined index: avatar_width

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 531

Notice

Undefined index: avatar_height

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 532

Notice

Undefined index: sig_img_width

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 534

Notice

Undefined index: sig_img_height

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 535

Notice

Undefined index: entry_date

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 536

Notice

Undefined index: site_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/Parser.php, line 553

Notice

Undefined index: entry_site_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Simple_variable.php, line 63

Notice

Undefined index: channel_url

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Simple_variable.php, line 64

Notice

Undefined index: comment_url

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Simple_variable.php, line 65

Notice

Undefined index: site_id

ee/legacy/libraries/channel_entries_parser/components/Custom_field.php, line 54

Warning

session_start(): Cannot start session when headers already sent

user/addons/gmaps/libraries/gmaps_library.php, line 40

Notice

Undefined variable: _SESSION

user/addons/gmaps/libraries/gmaps_library.php, line 41

Warning

session_start(): Cannot start session when headers already sent

user/addons/gmaps/libraries/gmaps_helper.php, line 565

Warning

session_start(): Cannot start session when headers already sent

user/addons/gmaps/libraries/gmaps_helper.php, line 565

Warning

Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at ee/legacy/core/Exceptions.php:120)

ee/EllisLab/ExpressionEngine/Boot/boot.common.php, line 493

Avoiding the “flaw of averages” in your LGPS actuarial valuation - Hymans Robertson

Blog

Avoiding the “flaw of averages” in your LGPS actuarial valuation

05 Oct 2021

Jeff Bezos walks into the room…and immediately we all become billionaires on average.

Those last two words are doing all the heavy lifting in that sentence! There’s no denying the arithmetic, but this is an example of what you might call the “flaw of averages”, i.e. where a statistic doesn’t necessarily help us.

The headline numbers in a typical pension scheme valuation report will be perfectly correct and will meet regulatory and professional requirements. However, they cannot be relied upon in isolation to make the best decisions when managing the Fund’s financial risks. They are subject to three variants (it feels strange using this word and not talking about Covid) of the “flaw of averages”.

Flaw 1: “Jeff Bezos walks into the room …”

Big numbers can obscure smaller ones, and in LGPS funding terms this usually means that the whole fund valuation results, in effect, just reflect the councils’ position. However, there will be dozens or hundreds of other employers in varying positions, each of whom needs to “tend its own field” within the fund. And there can be significant variety of employers’ position even within the same sector.

Furthermore, the same liability value change will impact individual employer contribution rates to different degrees depending on the ratio of payroll to obligations.

Lifting the bonnet on a valuation is really important to ensure you consider every employer, not just the big ones.

Flaw 2: “The average family has 2.4 children” 

Just as there are families of different sizes, there are employers with very different characteristics, and these variations exist in all LGPS funds already. For example, the same investment return will have a very different impact across the range of employers due to differences in employers’ funding levels, cashflow positions and time horizons.

It may be worth “kicking the tyres” on whether a fund’s single investment strategy is suitable across most employers, or whether additional strategies would serve some groups of employers better and justify the implementation?

And on climate change risk, funds should not place all their bets on a single chosen future outcome. “Stress testing” the investment and funding strategies against different potential outcomes will help ensure robustness to future climate outcomes.

Flaw 3: The “matching DNA” conundrum

There have been a number of miscarriage of justice cases, where people had been convicted on allegedly matching DNA with a crime scene, but were later found to be innocent: the conundrum is how their innocence squares with the “1 in a billion” type probabilities often quoted by prosecuting lawyers in court. The answer is that this tiny probability obscured greater likelihoods that there were (say) process errors in the DNA collection and matching. Ironically, it shows that a small number can obscure bigger ones.

In LGPS funding aspects, the whole fund picture will usually show minimal impacts from the McCloud remedy changes and ill-health early retirement strain costs; however, some employers will be much more affected by these than others. Funds will need to consider how best to engage with such cases, or in the case of ill health strains, explore how the risks and costs could be spread.

Don’t fall foul of the flaws

In summary, headline valuation figures are fine for statutory purposes, but do not present the full level of detail which will allow officers and other stakeholders to see the range of issues and situations facing individual employers. By avoiding such flaws of average, and working with the fund actuary, funds can be assured to make the right decisions arising from the next valuation.

If you would like to find out more, please get in touch

This blog also featured in Room 151.

Subscribe to our news and insights

0 comments on this post